Skip to content

Structured interview questions, with a scoring guide

By · Published · 4 min read

Hand-drawn illustration for the guide: Structured interview questions, with a scoring guide

A structured interview asks every candidate the same job-related questions, in the same order, and scores each answer against the same written guide. It is one of the most reliable ways to predict job performance, far better than a free-flowing conversation. To build one, list the four to six skills the job needs, write two questions for each, write what weak, average and strong answers look like, and have each interviewer score alone before anyone discusses the candidate.

Structured and unstructured interviews

UnstructuredStructured
Questions Whatever comes upSame for every candidate
Basis General impressionJob-related skills
Scoring Overall gut feelingEach answer against a written guide
Comparison Hard, because each interview differsFair, like for like
Prediction of Weaker performanceStronger

Build a structured interview in five steps

  1. List what the job needs. Talk to the hiring manager and a strong performer in the role. Choose four to six skills, such as planning, customer handling or problem solving.
  2. Write two questions per skill. Mix questions about past behaviour ("Tell me about a time...") with questions about realistic situations ("What would you do if...").
  3. Write a scoring guide. For each question, describe a 1, 3 and 5 answer.
  4. Fix the order and the follow-ups. Allow neutral prompts such as "What did you do next?" but not new questions.
  5. Score alone, then discuss. Each interviewer writes scores before the debrief.

20 example questions by skill

Planning and organising

  1. Tell me about a time you had several deadlines at once. How did you decide what to do first?
  2. You join a project that is two weeks behind. What do you do in your first two days?

Problem solving

  1. Describe a problem at work that had no obvious answer. How did you approach it?
  2. A process you own starts producing more errors. How would you find the cause?

Working with others

  1. Tell me about a time you disagreed with a colleague. What happened?
  2. A team member keeps missing handovers to you. What would you do?

Customer focus

  1. Tell me about a time a customer was unhappy with something you could not fully fix.
  2. A customer asks for something outside policy. How do you respond?

Learning and adapting

  1. Tell me about a skill you had to learn quickly. How did you do it?
  2. You receive feedback you disagree with. What do you do?

Ownership

  1. Tell me about a mistake you made at work. What did you do about it?
  2. You notice a problem that is not your responsibility. What do you do?

Communication

  1. Describe a time you had to explain something complex to someone without your background.
  2. You need a decision from a busy manager. How do you get it?

Influence

  1. Tell me about a time you persuaded someone to change their mind.
  2. Your idea is rejected in a meeting. What do you do next?

Leadership (for managers)

  1. Tell me about a time you dealt with a team member who was underperforming.
  2. Two of your team members are in conflict. How do you handle it?

Role-specific

  1. Walk me through how you would [a core task of the job].
  2. What would you check first if [a common problem in the job] happened?

A scoring guide with anchored answers

Example for question 11, "Tell me about a mistake you made at work."

ScoreWhat the answer looks like
1Cannot name a real mistake, or blames others
3Names a real mistake and fixed it, but little reflection on the cause
5Names a real mistake, owned it quickly, fixed it, told the right people and changed how they work so it does not happen again

Scores of 2 and 4 sit between the anchors.

Adding up the scores

Example: 5 skills, 2 questions each, scored 1 to 5. The maximum is 5 × 2 × 5 = 50. Set a minimum per skill as well as a total, so a high score in one area cannot hide a serious gap in another.

Common mistakes

  • Adding questions on the spot. Follow-ups are fine; new questions break the comparison.
  • Scoring at the end of the day. Memory fades and blends candidates. Score straight after each interview.
  • Discussing before scoring. The loudest view sets the others.
  • Asking about personal life. Stick to job-related questions. Questions about family plans, age, religion and similar topics may be unlawful and do not predict performance.

What the evidence says

That structured interviews predict job performance better than unstructured ones is Strong, from decades of research and several large reviews, including recent re-analyses that rank structured interviews among the best single predictors. That anchored scoring guides improve agreement between interviewers is Strong. The specific questions are Practice.

Frequently asked questions

What is a structured interview? An interview where every candidate is asked the same job-related questions in the same order, and each answer is scored against a written guide.

How many questions should a structured interview have? Usually eight to twelve: two for each of the four to six skills the job needs.

How do you score a structured interview? Use a 1 to 5 scale with written examples of weak, average and strong answers, and score each answer alone before discussing.

Check yourself

  1. What makes an interview structured? Same questions, same order, same scoring guide for every candidate.
  2. Five skills, two questions each, scored 1 to 5. What is the maximum? 50.
  3. Why score before the debrief? So one person's view does not set everyone else's.

Go deeper: free sample lesson

The Structured Interviewing course covers building, running and scoring structured interviews. Read the free sample lesson

Written by , founder of Dokimos. He is a senior product and UX designer based in Athens, and is studying for a BSc in Psychological Science.