Skip to content

Free sample · Module 1: Why interviews go wrong · 3 min read

What an interview can tell you

An interview has one main job: to help you predict how well a person will do a particular job. Everything else, including whether you enjoyed the conversation, matters only if it helps with that prediction. This sounds obvious, but it is easy to forget once two people start talking. A pleasant hour can feel like evidence when it is mostly a sign that the conversation went well.

An interview is a sample

In an interview you see a small sample of a person's behaviour: how they answer questions, explain their work, reason about a problem and respond to follow-ups. You also hear their account of what they have done before. From this sample you try to predict months or years of work.

Some things show up well in that sample:

  • Past behaviour, as described: what the person did in specific situations, which is one of the better guides to what they will do again.
  • Job knowledge: whether they understand the tools, methods and problems of the role.
  • Reasoning: how they think through a realistic situation they might face.
  • Spoken communication: how clearly they explain things, in roles where that matters.

Other things show up poorly, even though interviewers often believe they can see them:

  • Honesty and integrity: people who intend to mislead you are usually good at interviews.
  • Long-term potential: confident, fluent people often seem to have more of it than they do.
  • "Fit": without a clear definition, fit tends to mean "someone I liked" or "someone like us".
  • Performance in tasks you never asked about: a candidate who talks well about selling may not sell well.

Two jobs at once

An interview also does a second job. While you assess the candidate, the candidate assesses you. Good candidates often have other options, and the interview is one of the few direct experiences they have of your organisation. A rushed, disorganised or disrespectful interview can lose you the person you most wanted. Lesson 3.1 covers how to run an interview that is rigorous and still pleasant to sit through.

Start from the job, not the candidate

Because the interview is a prediction tool, you need to know what you are predicting before you start. That means a short, clear description of what good performance in the role looks like: the tasks that matter most, the problems the person will face and the standards they must meet. Without it, each interviewer assesses something different, and the decision comes down to whoever argues hardest. Module 2 shows how to turn a role into a short list of things to assess.

An example

Nikos runs a growing online shop in Thessaloniki and needs a customer support agent. He interviews three people. With the first two, the conversation is polite and a little stiff. With the third, Anna, it flows: they share a sense of humour and talk about their favourite places in the city. He hires her.

Three months later, Anna is popular with the team but struggles with angry customers and complicated refunds, which make up most of the job. Looking back, Nikos realises he never asked any candidate how they had handled an upset customer, or how they would deal with a refund that broke the usual rules. He assessed how well each person chatted with him, and the job was mostly about handling difficult conversations with strangers.

The common mistake

Interviewers treat the interview as a conversation to "get a feel" for the person. They come away with a strong impression and little evidence about the job. A better starting question is: what does this person need to do well in this role, and what will I ask to find out whether they can?

Evidence

Interviews as the most widely used selection method: Strong, found in surveys of employers across many countries. Candidates forming views of the employer from the interview: Strong that it happens, Mixed on how much it changes their decisions. Past behaviour as a guide to future behaviour in similar situations: Strong as a general principle, though people do change.

Remember

An interview is a short sample used to predict a long period of work. It can show past behaviour, job knowledge, reasoning and communication. It shows honesty, potential and undefined "fit" poorly. Decide what good performance looks like before you interview, and remember that the candidate is assessing you too.

[[drill:1]]

[[drill:2]]

[[drill:3]]

[[drill:4]]

[[drill:5]]

Drill 1

What is the main purpose of a job interview?

Drill 2

Which of these does an interview usually show poorly?

Drill 3

Why should you define good performance in the role before interviewing?

Drill 4

In the example, why did Nikos's hire struggle?

Drill 5

What is the second job an interview does, besides assessing the candidate?

Continue with the full Structured Interviewing course

4 modules, 100 drills and a final exam. Pass it to become Dokimos Certified in Structured Interviewing.