How to hire salespeople: interview questions and a scorecard
By Emmanuel Vasilakis · Published · 5 min read

To hire salespeople well, decide in advance the four to six things the role needs, ask every candidate the same questions about past behaviour and realistic situations, score each answer on a scale with examples, and add a short role-play of a real sales conversation. That structure predicts job performance far better than a free conversation and a gut feeling. Below are the questions, a role-play and a scorecard you can copy.
Start from the role, not the candidate
Before writing a single question, list what someone must do well to succeed in this specific job. For many B2B sales roles, the list looks like this:
- Prospecting and persistence: keeps creating opportunities when most attempts fail.
- Discovery: asks questions that uncover the buyer's problem and its cost.
- Clear communication: writes and speaks plainly, in the buyer's terms.
- Learning from feedback: changes behaviour after coaching.
- Organisation: manages many deals and follow-ups without dropping them.
- Integrity: does not overpromise to close a deal.
Adjust it. An account manager role might replace prospecting with growing existing accounts. Then write your questions to cover these criteria and nothing else.
Questions about past behaviour
Ask candidates to describe what they actually did in specific situations. Follow up with "What exactly did you say?" and "What happened next?" until you have the detail.
- Prospecting: "Tell me about a month when your pipeline was too thin. What did you do, day by day?"
- Persistence: "Describe a deal you won after the buyer had gone silent. How did you restart it?"
- Discovery: "Tell me about a deal where you found out the buyer's real problem was different from what they first said. How did you find out?"
- Learning: "Tell me about feedback from a manager that changed how you sell. What did you do differently afterwards?"
- Organisation: "How do you keep track of 40 open deals? Show me, or describe a typical Monday."
- Integrity: "Tell me about a time a buyer asked for something you couldn't deliver. What did you say?"
- Losing: "Tell me about a deal you lost that you should have won. What would you do differently?"
Questions about realistic situations
Describe a situation the candidate will face, and ask what they would do:
- "A prospect says your price is 30% above a competitor's. What do you do in the next five minutes of the call?"
- "You have three deals that could close this month and time to focus properly on only two. How do you choose?"
- "A buyer you've worked with for two months stops replying a week before the expected signature. What are your next three steps?"
A role-play that shows real skill
The best single test for a sales hire is a short simulation of the actual work. Give the candidate a one-page brief the day before: a fictional customer, their likely problem, and your product in plain terms. Then run a 15-minute first call, with an interviewer playing the buyer.
The interviewer should follow a script so that every candidate gets the same buyer: some information given freely, some only if asked, and one objection at a set point. Score what the candidate did, not how confident they sounded:
- Did they ask about the problem before presenting?
- Did they find the cost of the problem?
- Did they handle the objection by asking first?
- Did they agree a clear next step?
Avoid gimmicks such as "sell me this pen". They test confidence under pressure, not the skills the job needs.
The scorecard
Score each answer straight after the interview, on your own, before discussing with anyone else. Use a 1 to 5 scale with examples for at least 1, 3 and 5:
| Criterion | 1 (weak) | 3 (good) | 5 (strong) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Prospecting | Waited for leads; vague about activity | Increased outreach when pipeline was thin, with some specifics | Clear routine, numbers and adjustments when something wasn't working |
| Discovery | Described pitching the product | Asked about needs, some follow-up questions | Found the real problem and its cost, with specific questions quoted |
| Communication | Long, jargon-heavy answers | Clear, mostly concise | Plain, structured, in the buyer's terms |
| Learning | Defensive about feedback, or no example | Example of feedback acted on | Specific change, sustained, with results |
| Organisation | No system | Uses CRM and reminders | Clear system, priorities and follow-up habits |
| Integrity | Would promise to close | Would check before promising | Said no clearly, kept the relationship |
| Role-play | Pitched immediately; no next step | Some discovery; next step agreed | Discovery, cost, objection handled by asking, dated next step |
Add the scores, and decide your minimums in advance. For example, you might require at least 3 on discovery and integrity whatever the total.
Keep it lawful and fair
Ask every candidate the same job-related questions. Do not ask about age, family plans, health, nationality, religion or anything else unrelated to the work. In the EU, pay transparency rules being introduced from 2026 restrict asking candidates about their pay history and require you to share the pay range. Check your national rules. This is not legal advice.
What the evidence says
That structured interviews, with set questions and scored answers, predict job performance better than unstructured ones is Strong, from decades of research. That work samples such as a role-play are among the better predictors is Strong. The specific criteria and questions for sales roles are Practice.
Frequently asked questions
What are the best interview questions for salespeople? Questions about specific past situations, such as rebuilding a thin pipeline or restarting a silent deal, followed by "what exactly did you say?"
Should I use a role-play in a sales interview? Yes. A short, scripted first-call simulation is one of the best tests of real sales skill.
Is "sell me this pen" a good interview question? No. It tests confidence under pressure rather than discovery, communication or persistence.
Check yourself
- Why ask every candidate the same questions? So answers can be compared fairly and scored against the same standard.
- What should a role-play score? What the candidate did, such as discovery and next steps, not how confident they sounded.
- When should interviewers discuss candidates? After scoring independently.
Go deeper: free sample lesson
The Structured Interviewing course covers scorecards, consistent questions and fair hiring decisions.
Related guides
- A 30-60-90 day onboarding plan for new salespeople
A practical 30-60-90 day plan for onboarding salespeople: what to learn, when to sell alone, how to ramp quota, and the checkpoints that show progress.
- How to coach salespeople: a one-to-one meeting template
A 30-minute weekly sales coaching template: what to cover, the questions to ask, how to choose one skill to work on and how to follow up.
- Structured interview questions, with a scoring guide
What a structured interview is, how to build one in five steps, 20 example questions by competency, a 1 to 5 scoring guide with anchored answers and the mistakes to avoid.
- Behavioural interview questions and how to score the answers
What behavioural interview questions are, 15 examples, how to probe for real detail, how to tell a strong answer from a rehearsed one, and a worked scoring example.

