Behavioural interview questions and how to score the answers
By Emmanuel Vasilakis · Published · 4 min read

Behavioural interview questions ask candidates to describe what they actually did in a past situation, usually starting "Tell me about a time...". They work because past behaviour in similar situations is a useful guide to future behaviour. A good answer covers the situation, what the candidate personally did and what happened as a result. Your job as interviewer is to probe until you have specific detail, then score the answer against a guide you wrote before the interview.
Why behavioural questions work
Ask "How do you handle conflict?" and most people give an ideal answer. Ask "Tell me about the last time you disagreed with a colleague" and you hear what they did. Real examples are harder to invent, and follow-up questions quickly show whether the story holds together.
15 behavioural interview questions
- Tell me about a time you had to meet a deadline that looked impossible.
- Describe a time you made a mistake that affected someone else.
- Tell me about a time you disagreed with your manager.
- Give an example of a time you changed how something was done.
- Tell me about a time you had to work with someone you found difficult.
- Describe a decision you made without all the information you wanted.
- Tell me about a time you received critical feedback.
- Give an example of a goal you did not reach. What happened?
- Tell me about a time you helped a colleague who was struggling.
- Describe a time a customer or stakeholder was unhappy with you.
- Tell me about a time you had to learn something new quickly.
- Give an example of when you spotted a problem before others did.
- Tell me about a time you had to say no to a request.
- Describe a project that went wrong. What was your part in it?
- Tell me about a time you persuaded a group to try your approach.
Choose the ones that match the skills the job needs. Do not use all 15.
The three parts of a good answer
| Part | What you want to hear | Probe if missing |
|---|---|---|
| Situation | Brief context: where, when, what was at stake | "When was this? What was your role?" |
| Action | What they did, step by step | "What did you do yourself? What did you say?" |
| Result | What happened, ideally with a number, and what they learned | "What was the outcome? What would you do differently?" |
Most weak answers spend too long on the situation and too little on the action.
Probing for real detail
- "We" or "I"? "You said 'we'. What was your part?"
- Specifics. "What exactly did you say to her?"
- Sequence. "What did you do first? Then what?"
- Alternatives. "What else did you consider?" Reflection. "Looking back, what would you change?"
Keep probes neutral. "That must have been hard" leads the candidate; "What happened next?" does not.
Rehearsed or real?
| Signs of a rehearsed answer | Signs of a real one |
|---|---|
| Smooth, general, no names or numbers | Specific details: people, dates, figures |
| Falls apart when you probe | Gets richer when you probe |
| Always "we", rarely "I" | Clear about their own actions |
| Perfect ending, no learning | Admits what went wrong |
Preparation is not cheating. Candidates who prepared real examples are fine. The issue is answers with no real event behind them.
A worked scoring example
Question: "Tell me about a time you made a mistake that affected someone else."
Scoring guide:
- 1: No real example, or blames others.
- 3: Real example, fixed it, limited reflection.
- 5: Real example, owned it quickly, told those affected, fixed it and changed how they work.
Answer: "I sent a client the wrong price list. When I noticed two days later, I called the client first, apologised and sent the right one. I told my manager the same day. The client had already shared it internally, so I offered to join their call to explain. Afterwards I added a check to our template so the list version shows on the first page."
Score: 5. Real event, owned it, informed people affected, fixed it and prevented a repeat.
What the evidence says
That past-behaviour questions in a structured interview predict job performance is Strong, with comparable support for well-designed situational ("What would you do?") questions. That probing improves the quality of information is Mixed: helpful when neutral, harmful when it leads. The questions and scoring example are Practice.
Frequently asked questions
What are behavioural interview questions? Questions that ask candidates to describe what they actually did in a past situation, such as "Tell me about a time you disagreed with your manager."
How do you score behavioural interview answers? Write a guide before the interview describing weak, average and strong answers, probe for specific detail, then score each answer on a 1 to 5 scale.
What makes a good answer? Brief context, a clear account of what the candidate personally did, and the result, including what they learned.
Check yourself
- What are the three parts of a good answer? Situation, action and result.
- A candidate keeps saying "we". What do you ask? "What was your part?"
- Which part do weak answers usually skimp on? The action.
Go deeper: free sample lesson
The Structured Interviewing course covers behavioural and situational questions, probing and scoring. Read the free sample lesson
Related guides
- Structured interview questions, with a scoring guide
What a structured interview is, how to build one in five steps, 20 example questions by competency, a 1 to 5 scoring guide with anchored answers and the mistakes to avoid.
- Interview scorecard template, with a worked example
A copyable interview scorecard template: what to include, how to weight skills, set minimum scores, combine several interviewers' ratings and run a fair debrief.
- How to reduce bias in hiring interviews
The common biases in hiring interviews, why awareness training alone rarely fixes them, and ten process changes that do, from structured questions to independent scoring.
- How to hire salespeople: interview questions and a scorecard
Interview questions for hiring salespeople, a role-play exercise, and a scoring sheet with examples of weak and strong answers, built on what predicts performance.

