Skip to content

Interview scorecard template, with a worked example

By · Published · 3 min read

Hand-drawn illustration for the guide: Interview scorecard template, with a worked example

An interview scorecard lists the skills a job needs, the questions that test each one, a 1 to 5 rating scale with written anchors, and space for evidence. Each interviewer fills it in alone straight after the interview. Weight the skills by importance, set a minimum score for the essential ones, and only then add up a total. The scorecard turns impressions into evidence and makes candidates comparable.

What a scorecard includes

  1. Role and candidate details.
  2. Skills to assess, usually four to six, each with a weight.
  3. The questions for each skill.
  4. A rating scale with a short description of 1, 3 and 5.
  5. Evidence notes: what the candidate said or did, not your opinion.
  6. A minimum score for each essential skill.
  7. An overall recommendation, made last.

The template

  • SkillWeight Questions Evidence (what they said or did) Score (1 to 5) Minimum
  • [Skill 1] [ ]%[Q1, Q2][3]
  • [Skill 2] [ ]%[Q3, Q4][3]
  • [Skill 3] [ ]%[Q5, Q6][ ]
  • [Skill 4] [ ]%[Q7, Q8][ ]

A worked example

Role: customer success manager. Four skills, with weights that add up to 100%.

SkillWeightScoreWeighted
Customer handling30%41.2
Problem solving30%30.9
Communication20%51.0
Planning20%20.4

Total100%3.5

The weighted score is 3.5 out of 5, which looks fine. But planning is an essential skill with a minimum of 3, and the candidate scored 2. The minimum rule flags the gap, so the panel discusses it with evidence rather than letting a strong communication score hide it.

Combining several interviewers

When two or three people interview the same candidate:

  • Each scores alone, before talking to anyone.
  • Average the scores per skill. Example: planning scores of 2, 3 and 2 give an average of 7 ÷ 3 ≈ 2.3.
  • Discuss large gaps. If one person gives 5 and another gives 2, ask each for their evidence. Often one of them saw something the other missed.
  • Change scores only on evidence, not on persuasion.

Running a fair debrief

  1. Everyone submits their scorecard first.
  2. The hiring manager speaks last, so seniority does not set the tone.
  3. Go skill by skill, not "so, what did everyone think?"
  4. Record the decision and the main reason.

Common mistakes

MistakeFix
Writing "good culture fit" as evidenceWrite what the candidate said or did
Filling in the scorecard the next dayFill it in within an hour
Changing the skills between candidatesFix them before the first interview
Recommending first, scoring laterScore each skill, then recommend

What the evidence says

That combining ratings mechanically (adding weighted scores) predicts performance better than overall judgement is Strong, from decades of research on mechanical and holistic decisions. That scoring alone before discussion reduces group pressure is Mixed, supported by research on group judgement. The template is Practice.

Frequently asked questions

What is an interview scorecard? A form listing the skills a job needs, the questions for each, a rating scale with anchors and space for evidence, filled in by each interviewer alone.

How do you weight an interview scorecard? Give each skill a percentage by importance so the weights add up to 100%, multiply each score by its weight and add them up.

Should a high total always mean a hire? No. Set minimum scores for essential skills so a strength in one area cannot hide a gap in another.

Check yourself

  1. A skill weighted 30% is scored 4. What is its weighted score? 1.2.
  2. Why set minimum scores? So a high total cannot hide a gap in an essential skill.
  3. Who should speak last in a debrief? The hiring manager.

Go deeper: free sample lesson

The Structured Interviewing course covers scorecards, combining ratings and running debriefs. Read the free sample lesson

Written by , founder of Dokimos. He is a senior product and UX designer based in Athens, and is studying for a BSc in Psychological Science.