Skip to content

How to give constructive feedback, with examples

By · Published · 4 min read

Hand-drawn illustration for the guide: How to give constructive feedback, with examples

Constructive feedback describes a specific behaviour, explains its effect and agrees what happens next. Use four steps: say what you saw, say what effect it had, ask for their view, and agree a change together. Give it soon after the event, in private, and about the work rather than the person. Keep it short. Most feedback goes wrong because it is vague, late, or sounds like a judgement of character.

The four steps

StepWhat you sayExample
1. What you sawA specific, observable behaviour"In this morning's client call, you interrupted Anna three times while she was presenting the figures."
2. The effectWhat it led to, for the work or others"The client started asking you instead of her, and she didn't get to finish the key point on costs."
3. Their viewAn open question, then listen"How did it look from your side?"
4. What nextAgree a change together"For Thursday's call, could you hold your points until she's finished, and we'll leave five minutes at the end for you?"

Step 3 matters most. You may have missed something, and people are far more likely to change when they have had a say.

Weak and strong feedback

WeakWhy it failsStrong
"You need to be more professional."Vague, and sounds like a judgement of the person"You arrived 15 minutes late to the last two client meetings."
"Great job!"Nice, but teaches nothing"The summary at the top of your report meant the director could decide in five minutes."
"Everyone thinks you're negative."Unverifiable and unfair"In today's meeting, you said 'that won't work' to three ideas before they were explained."
"Why do you always do this?""Always" invites an argument"This is the second report this month that arrived after the deadline."

Timing and place

  • Soon: within a day or two, while details are fresh.
  • In private for improvement feedback. Praise can be public if the person is comfortable with it.
  • Not in the middle of stress: if someone has just had a bad meeting, give them an hour.
  • Often and small: regular short feedback is easier to hear than a long list saved for a review.

Why the feedback sandwich often fails

The "sandwich" puts criticism between two pieces of praise. People learn the pattern and start to ignore the praise, or miss the criticism because it is buried. Be direct and kind instead: say the point clearly, explain why, and give praise separately when it is earned.

When the person gets defensive

  • Stay calm and curious. "It sounds like you see it differently. Tell me more."
  • Go back to the specific behaviour. "I'm only talking about Tuesday's call."
  • Separate the person from the action. "I think you're good with clients. This one moment didn't help." Pause if needed. "Let's pick this up tomorrow after we've both thought about it."

An example

Dimitra manages a support team. One of her team, Stelios, has been closing tickets without confirming the fix with customers.

Stelios explains he was trying to hit the daily target. Dimitra agrees that confirmed fixes will count, and they decide he will send a short check message and close only after a reply or 48 hours.

What the evidence says

That feedback improves performance on average, but makes it worse in a substantial minority of cases, is Strong, from large reviews of feedback research. That feedback about the task works better than feedback about the person is Strong. That the feedback sandwich is ineffective is Mixed: little direct research, but consistent with findings on clarity. The four steps are Practice.

Frequently asked questions

How do you give constructive feedback? Describe a specific behaviour, explain its effect, ask for the person's view, and agree what happens next.

What is an example of constructive feedback? "In the client call, you interrupted Anna three times, so she couldn't finish the cost point. How did it look to you? Could you hold your points until she's done next time?"

Should I use the feedback sandwich? Usually not. It can hide the point. Be clear and kind, and give praise separately when it is earned.

Check yourself

  1. What are the four steps? What you saw, the effect, their view, what next.
  2. Why avoid "always" and "never"? They invite an argument about the exceptions.
  3. Why ask for their view? You may have missed something, and people change more when they have a say.

Go deeper: free sample lesson

The Giving Feedback course covers preparing, delivering and following up on feedback. Read the free sample lesson

Written by , founder of Dokimos. He is a senior product and UX designer based in Athens, and is studying for a BSc in Psychological Science.