Skip to content

How to manage an underperforming salesperson fairly

By · Published · 5 min read

Hand-drawn illustration for the guide: How to manage an underperforming salesperson fairly

To manage an underperforming salesperson fairly, first check the numbers properly, comparing like with like over enough time. Then find the cause: missing knowledge, a skill gap, low motivation, or something in their situation such as a weak territory or poor leads. Have a direct, specific conversation, agree a written plan with clear goals, support and a timeframe, review it regularly, and only then decide. Each step protects both the salesperson and the business.

Step 1: check the data

Before deciding someone is underperforming, make sure the comparison is fair:

  • Over enough time. One bad month in a business with three-month sales cycles says little. Look at two or three quarters where possible.
  • Like with like. Compare with people in similar territories, account types and tenure.
  • Leading measures too. Is the problem results only, or also activity, pipeline creation and conversion? The pattern points to the cause.
  • Context. Absence, a ramp period, territory changes, a product problem or a lost major account can all explain a dip.

A quick diagnostic table helps:

MeasureThis personTeam average (similar territories)
Revenue against quota, last two quarters62%96%
New qualified pipeline per month€40,000€75,000
Win rate28%27%
Average deal size€9,500€10,000

In this example, win rate and deal size are normal. The problem is pipeline creation, which points to prospecting, not closing.

Step 2: find the cause

Most performance problems come from one of four places:

CauseSignsTypical response
KnowledgeUnsure about product, process or pricingTraining, job aids, shadowing
SkillKnows what to do but does it poorlyCoaching on one skill at a time, with observation
MotivationCan do it but does notA direct conversation about what has changed; goals and consequences
SituationWeak territory, poor leads, missing tools, personal circumstancesFix what the business controls; support where appropriate

Ask before you decide. The salesperson often knows the cause, or knows part of it.

Step 3: have the conversation

Book a private meeting with notice. Be specific and calm:

"I want to talk about your results. Over the last two quarters you've reached 62% of quota, against a team average of 96%. Your win rate is in line with the team, but you're creating about half as much new pipeline. I'd like to understand what's going on from your side."

Then listen. Ask what is getting in the way and what would help. If personal circumstances come up, such as illness or caring responsibilities, respond with care, avoid probing for details and record only what is necessary.

Step 4: agree a written plan

A plan should be specific enough to check, realistic, and supported. A template:

SectionExample
GapNew qualified pipeline €40,000 a month against a team norm of €75,000
GoalAt least €65,000 of new qualified pipeline a month by the end of month two
Leading actions25 first conversations a week with prospects who fit the profile; two LinkedIn sessions a week
SupportWeekly coaching on first calls using recordings; access to marketing's account list; one joint call a week with the manager
Check-insWeekly 30-minute review; formal review at weeks 4 and 8
TimeframeEight weeks
What happens nextAgreed in writing: what success means, and what happens if goals are not met

Share the plan, check that it is understood, and give a copy.

Step 5: review and decide

Hold the check-ins you agreed. Note progress honestly, including what improves. At the end, there are usually three outcomes:

  • Improvement: acknowledge it clearly, and move back to normal coaching.
  • Partial improvement: extend with adjusted goals if progress is real and the remaining gap is closing.
  • No improvement: consider a different role that fits the person better, or move to a formal process.

Formal steps such as warnings or dismissal are governed by national employment law, contracts and company procedures, which vary widely. Involve HR or an employment adviser before taking them. This guide is not legal advice.

Keep it fair

  • Apply the same standards to everyone in similar roles.
  • Base everything on observed behaviour and results, not impressions.
  • Do not let protected characteristics, such as age, pregnancy or disability, influence the process; where a disability is involved, consider reasonable adjustments.
  • Keep factual notes, and assume the person may ask to see them, which under the GDPR they often can.

What the evidence says

That specific goals combined with regular feedback improve performance is Strong. The four-cause diagnosis and the improvement plan structure are Practice, common in sales management and HR. The legal points are general and not graded.

Frequently asked questions

How do you handle an underperforming sales rep? Check the data fairly, find the cause, have a specific conversation, agree a written plan with support and a timeframe, then review and decide.

How long should a sales performance improvement plan last? Long enough for results to show given your sales cycle, often six to twelve weeks, measured on leading indicators as well as revenue.

When should you let an underperforming salesperson go? Only after a fair plan, real support and documented reviews, and after checking national rules and company procedures.

Check yourself

  1. A salesperson's win rate is normal but pipeline creation is half the team's. Where is the problem likely to be? Prospecting and pipeline creation.
  2. Which measures should an improvement plan include besides revenue? Leading measures, such as conversations held and pipeline created.
  3. Who should be involved before formal steps? HR or an employment adviser.

Go deeper: free sample lesson

The Giving Feedback course covers hard conversations about performance, handled fairly.

Written by , founder of Dokimos. He is a senior product and UX designer based in Athens, and is studying for a BSc in Psychological Science.