Free sample · Module 1: Why feedback goes wrong · 4 min read
What feedback is for
Feedback is information about how someone's actions compare with a goal or a standard, given so that they can do better or keep doing what works. That definition sounds dry, but it rules out a lot of what passes for feedback at work: a general mood ("things are fine"), a verdict with no detail ("that was poor"), or a complaint about someone that never reaches them.
Why people need it
People cannot see themselves from the outside. Research comparing self-ratings with ratings from colleagues, managers and objective measures finds only a weak link between how good people think they are and how good they are. The gap is often widest for skills that are hard to judge from the inside, such as how clearly you explain things or how you come across in a meeting. Feedback closes part of that gap. It tells a person what others see, which they cannot find out alone.
Feedback also tells people what matters. When a manager comments on punctuality but never on the quality of the work, the team learns that punctuality is what counts. What you choose to give feedback on is a signal, whether you intend it or not.
Three things that get called feedback
Much confusion comes from mixing up three different things:
- Appreciation: recognising effort or a result, and showing that it was noticed. "Thank you for staying late to finish the order."
- Guidance: information about how to do something better, or what to keep doing. "The report was clear. Next time, put the cost table on the first page, because that is what the client reads first."
- Evaluation: where the person stands against a standard or against others. "Your sales this quarter were below target."
Each has its place, and each needs a different conversation. Problems start when they are mixed. A person who hears an evaluation ("this is below what we expect") tends to stop listening to the guidance that follows, because they are thinking about what the evaluation means for them. A person who only ever hears appreciation has nothing to improve on. A person who only hears evaluation knows where they stand but not what to do.
A useful habit is to decide, before you speak, which of the three you are giving. If you need to give two, consider separating them, for example evaluation in a review and guidance in a later, shorter conversation.
What feedback is not
Feedback is not the same as criticism. Telling someone what to keep doing is feedback, and it is often more useful than telling them what to stop. Feedback is also not an annual event. A once-a-year conversation cannot replace the small, frequent comments that help people adjust while the work is still fresh.
Finally, feedback is not a judgement of the person. It is about what they did, in a particular situation, and what effect it had. Later lessons explain why that distinction matters so much.
An example
Eleni runs three bakeries in Patras. Every Friday she tells each shift lead "good job this week". When one of them, Stelios, starts leaving the morning display half empty, she says nothing for a month, then raises it sharply during a busy Saturday. Stelios is surprised and defensive: in his view, he has been told every week that he is doing well.
Eleni was giving appreciation with no content, then an evaluation with no warning. Neither told Stelios what she expected or why. A short comment in the first week ("The display was half empty at 9 on Tuesday. Morning customers buy what they see, so I need it full by 8") would have been guidance he could act on.
The common mistake
People treat feedback as something you do when there is a problem. As a result, most feedback arrives late, is negative and carries the weight of everything left unsaid. The person receiving it hears a verdict rather than information.
Evidence
The weak link between self-assessment and other measures of performance is Strong, found across many studies and reviews. The idea that people respond differently to appreciation, guidance and evaluation, and that mixing them causes problems, is Practice: widely taught by experienced practitioners, with some support from research on how evaluation draws attention to the self. The claim that frequent, small feedback beats rare, large feedback is Mixed: it fits what is known about learning, but workplace studies vary.
Remember
Feedback is information about how actions compare with a goal, given so that someone can improve or keep doing what works. People need it because they cannot see themselves from outside. Decide whether you are giving appreciation, guidance or evaluation, and do not let one drown out another.
[[drill:1]]
[[drill:2]]
[[drill:3]]
[[drill:4]]
[[drill:5]]
Continue with the full Giving Feedback course
4 modules, 100 drills and a final exam. Pass it to become Dokimos Certified in Giving Feedback.

