Skip to content

From top seller to sales manager: what changes and what to stop doing

By · Published · 5 min read

Hand-drawn illustration for the guide: From top seller to sales manager: what changes and what to stop doing

When a top salesperson becomes a sales manager, the job changes from winning deals to helping other people win them. Success is now measured through the team. The habits that made you a great seller, such as taking over difficult deals, keeping your best accounts and doing things your own way, often get in the way. Stop rescuing deals, hand over your accounts, and spend most of your time on one-to-ones, coaching, pipeline reviews, hiring and forecasting.

What actually changes

As a sellerAs a manager
Your results come from your dealsYour results come from the team's deals
You control your own workYou influence other people's work
Quick feedback: a deal won or lostSlow feedback: a skill improving over months
You are judged on your numberYou are judged on the team's number and how you got it
Your peers are colleaguesSome of your former peers now report to you

Many new managers find the slower feedback the hardest part. A week of coaching does not produce a closed deal by Friday.

What to stop doing

Rescuing deals. Taking over a difficult deal feels productive and may win it. It also teaches the team that hard deals go to you, removes their chance to learn and leaves you no time to manage. Join calls to coach, with roles agreed in advance.

Keeping your accounts. Hand them over properly, with introductions. Keeping "just a few" means you will always choose your own deals over your team when time is short.

Judging everyone by your style. You succeeded in one way. Others can succeed in different ways. Coach towards results and sound methods, not towards copies of yourself.

Solving every problem yourself. When someone brings you a problem, ask what they think first. Answering immediately is faster today and slower forever.

Being one of the team in the same way. You can stay friendly, but you now decide on targets, territories and sometimes jobs. Pretending nothing has changed makes those decisions harder later.

What to start doing

  • Weekly one-to-ones with each person, focused on their deals and their development.
  • Coaching one skill at a time, based on calls and emails you have observed.
  • Pipeline reviews and forecasting on a weekly rhythm.
  • Hiring and onboarding, which shape your team for years.
  • Managing up: regular, honest updates to your own manager, including bad news early.
  • Working across teams: marketing, customer success, finance and product.

A sample week

ActivityHours
One-to-ones (six people × 30 to 45 minutes)4
Joining calls to coach5
Pipeline review and forecast3
Preparing coaching and reviewing calls3
Hiring and onboarding3
Meetings with your manager and other teams4
Administration, reporting, planning4
Thinking time: priorities, problems, ideas2
Total28 of about 40

The remaining time disappears into everything unplanned. Notice what is not on the list: selling your own deals.

Managing former peers

The first weeks set the tone. A few habits help:

  • Acknowledge the change openly in a one-to-one: "This is a bit strange for both of us. I'd like to keep working well together, and I'll need to make some decisions you might not like."
  • Ask what they need from a manager. Their answers are often more practical than you expect.
  • Be consistent. Apply the same standards to former friends and to everyone else. Favouritism, or bending over backwards to avoid it, both damage trust.
  • If someone else wanted the job, talk about it directly and early. Ask what they want to develop, and help them work towards it.

Why top sellers sometimes struggle

The skills that make a great seller and a great manager overlap only partly. One widely cited study of sales organisations found that firms tended to promote their best salespeople, and that those promoted salespeople tended to perform worse as managers than colleagues promoted for other reasons. That does not mean top sellers cannot manage well. It means the move needs preparation, and that selling skill alone is not evidence of management skill.

An example

Stavros was the top seller at an industrial supplies distributor in Thessaloniki. In his first two months as manager, he joined almost every important call and usually ended up leading it. The team's results held up, but two of his people told him in their one-to-ones that they felt sidelined. Stavros agreed a rule: on joint calls, the salesperson leads, and he speaks only at an agreed moment or if asked. He spent the time he saved on weekly coaching. By the next quarter, two of his salespeople had closed their largest deals without him.

What the evidence says

That promoted top salespeople, on average, can perform worse as managers than others comes mainly from one large, well-known study and is Mixed: credible, but more research is needed. That regular coaching and feedback improve performance is Strong in general and Mixed for sales coaching specifically. The habits and sample week are Practice.

Frequently asked questions

Do top salespeople make good sales managers? Some do, but selling skill alone does not predict management skill. The move needs preparation and new habits.

How should a new sales manager spend their time? Mainly on one-to-ones, coaching, pipeline reviews, forecasting, hiring and working with their own manager and other teams.

How do you manage former peers? Acknowledge the change openly, ask what they need, and apply the same standards to everyone.

Check yourself

  1. Why is rescuing deals a problem for a new manager? It teaches the team to hand over hard deals, removes their learning and leaves no time to manage.
  2. What should you do with your old accounts? Hand them over properly, with introductions.
  3. Name two new responsibilities of a sales manager. Any two of: one-to-ones, coaching, pipeline reviews, forecasting, hiring, managing up.

Go deeper: free sample lesson

The Giving Feedback course covers the feedback and coaching skills a new manager needs most.

Written by , founder of Dokimos. He is a senior product and UX designer based in Athens, and is studying for a BSc in Psychological Science.