Skip to content

Free sample · Module 4: Telling the story · 3 min read

Honesty and realistic previews

It is tempting to show only the best side of a job. But every job has hard parts, and people find them out in their first weeks. When the reality surprises them, many leave. A realistic job preview tells candidates the truth, good and bad, before they decide. It is one of the best-researched ideas in recruitment.

What a realistic preview is

A realistic job preview gives candidates accurate information about the job, including its downsides, before they accept an offer. It can be:

  • a section of the job ad called "What's hard about this job"
  • a video of a real shift, including the difficult parts
  • a conversation with someone doing the job
  • a site visit or a trial day
  • a short questionnaire asking candidates how they would feel about specific demands

Why it works

Research suggests several reasons:

  • Self-selection: people who would not cope or would not like it decide not to apply or not to accept.
  • Expectations: people who join know what to expect, so the hard parts do not feel like broken promises.
  • Coping: knowing in advance helps people prepare for difficulties.
  • Trust: being honest signals that the organisation can be trusted, which builds commitment.

The effects on turnover are real but moderate. Realistic previews are not a cure for a bad job, but they reduce the share of people who leave because the job was not what they expected.

What to include

The things that most often surprise new starters. You can find them in:

  • exit interviews of people who left in their first six months
  • onboarding feedback
  • conversations with managers and recent joiners: "What do people not expect?"

Typical examples: shift patterns, physical demands, travel, difficult customers, busy seasons, targets, the pace of change, limited flexibility in certain roles.

How to say it

Be specific and calm, and pair the difficulty with how the organisation helps:

What's hard about this job. In July and August, kitchen shifts run 10 hours, six days a week. It is hot and fast. We pay overtime, provide meals on every shift, and rotate staff so nobody works more than three late shifts in a row.

Avoid dramatising, and avoid apologising. You are describing the job, not warning people off it.

When to share it

As early as possible, so people self-select before investing time. The job ad is a good place for the main points, with more detail at interview. Leaving it until the offer stage means people have already made up their minds and may feel misled.

Will it cut applications?

Sometimes, a little. That is the point: fewer people who would leave early, more who would stay. Track suitable applicants, offer acceptance and early turnover together, not applications alone.

An example

A call centre in Athens loses 40% of new starters within three months. Exit interviews show that most did not expect the call volume or the scripted calls about billing disputes. The company adds a short section to job ads and a 20-minute session at interview where candidates listen to two real (anonymised) calls and talk to an agent. Applications fall by about 10%. Early leavers fall from 40% to 28% over the next six months.

The common mistake

Treating honesty as a risk to the employer brand. Dishonesty is the risk: it turns into early resignations, negative reviews and lost trust.

Evidence

That realistic job previews reduce turnover by a modest amount is Strong, from several meta-analyses. That their effect works partly through perceived honesty of the employer is Mixed, supported by later research. That previews given earlier are more effective than those given later is Mixed. The wording advice is Practice.

Remember

Tell candidates what is hard about the job, early, specifically and calmly, with what the organisation does to help. Realistic previews improve self-selection, expectations and trust, and reduce early turnover. Judge them by retention, not by application numbers.

[[drill:1]]

[[drill:2]]

[[drill:3]]

[[drill:4]]

[[drill:5]]

Drill 1

What is a realistic job preview?

Drill 2

Which is one of the reasons realistic previews reduce turnover?

Drill 3

Where can you find what most often surprises new starters?

Drill 4

When should a realistic preview usually be shared?

Drill 5

In the call centre example, what happened to early leavers?

Continue with the full Employer Branding course

10 modules, 250 drills and a final exam. Pass it to become Dokimos Certified in Employer Branding.

See the Employer Branding syllabus